Story Summary

Oil, Gas and Pipeline Companies Sued for Louisiana Coastal Land Loss and Flood Risk

Oil, gas and pipeline companies that cut at least 10,000 miles of oil and gas canals and pipelines through Louisiana coastal lands must repair the damaged environmental buffer zone that helps protect most of the greater New Orleans region from catastrophic flooding, a lawsuit filed by the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority – East (SLFPA-E) asserted in a lawsuit filed in state district court in Orleans Parish on Wed Jul 24, 2013.

Story Timeline
Previous Next
This story has 4 updates

WGNO News has obtained the full text of the lawsuit filed against 97 oil and gas and related companies by the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority – East (SLFPA-E).

Read the full text of the lawsuit here: Full text – oil & gas coastal erosion lawsuit

If you owned something that would produce say… golden eggs, would you allow your work boss to just claim he owned 80% of the eggs because you worked for him? Since most of you aren’t related to Marc Morial and said “no” let’s proceed.

The people of the state of Louisiana own the oil fields that lay “black gold” eggs in the Gulf of Mexico. I like to remind you that our state’s charter, the Constitution of 1812, EXPLICITLY says that the state’s borders “includ[e] all Islands within three leagues of the coast.”(1) This should mean that the state’s coastline extends about 10 miles into the Gulf. The reason this is important rests on the amount of royalties due this state from the sale of oil leases and the revenue they generate in those 10 miles.

Now, there is the issue of the aforementioned land eroding into the sea and the Coastal Protection and Restoration Authority’s Sisyphaen efforts(2) to stop it, but they forgot to account for the most destructive force of all: trial lawyers.

A suit has recently been filed that asks various oil companies to fork over $100 million(3) to the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority-East which has been locally tasked with coastal protection as well. Of course, the Authority will only receive $68 of those millions while the ambulance chasers pocket the rest.

Governor Jindal has demanded of the Authority that their suit be dropped saying it violates the Legislature’s Act while reminding the press that this process will cost $50 billion over 50 years. Yes, that sounds like a lot until you consider the $200 BILLION booty the state has paid the Feds in offshore royalties since the Submerged Lands Act of 1953. (4)

Jindal is spot on to say a better way to deal with our coast is to reclaim control of our waters, keep 90 percent of that royalty revenue in the state and assess the energy company’s an impost on production to fund restoration. The only way this plan will work is to take Shakespeare’s advice and deal with the trial lawyers.(5)

1. http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Louisiana_State_Constitution_of_1812

“We, the Representatives of the People of all that part of the Territory or country ceded under the name of Louisiana, by the treaty made at Paris, on the 30th day of April 1803, between the United States and France, contained in the following limits, to wit; beginning at the mouth of the river Sabine, ‘thence by a line to be drawn along the middle of said river, including all its islands, to the thirty second degree of latitude—thence due north to the Northernmost part of the thirty third degree of north latitude—thence along the said parallel of latitude to the river Mississippi— thence down the said river to the river Iberville, and from thence along the middle of the said river and lakes Maurepas and Pontchartrain to the Gulf of Mexico—thence bounded by the said Gulf to the place of beginning, including all Islands within three leagues of the coast—in Convention Assembled by virtue of an act of Congress, entitled “an act to enable the people of the Territory of Orleans to form a constitution and State government and for the admission of said State into the Union on an equal footing with the original States, and for other purpose :“ In order to secure to all the citizens thereof the enjoyment of the right of Life, Liberty and property, do ordain and establish the following constitution or form of government, and do mutually agree with each other to form ourselves into a free and independent State, by the name of the State of Louisiana.”

2. http://www.mythweb.com/encyc/entries/sisyphus.html In Greek mythology Sisyphus is doomed to roll a stone up and over a hill but every time he nears the crest the stone rolls back down the hill.

3. http://www.nola.com/environment/index.ssf/2013/07/jindal_demands_east_bank_levee.html#incart_maj-story-2

4. http://www.boem.gov/uploadedFiles/submergedLA.pdf

5. http://www.enotes.com/shakespeare-quotes/lets-kill-all-lawyers

The Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority-East is suing nearly 100 oil companies.

The group is responsible for operating and maintaining the levee, floodgates and seawall protection on the East Bank.

It claims the oil companies failed to repair damage they caused to coastal wetlands which help protect the Greater New Orleans area from catastrophic flooding.

Governor Bobby Jindal wants the group to pull the lawsuit. He says it’s overstepping its bounds.

Both the Louisiana Oil and Gas Association and Jindal think the lawsuit is a way for lawyers to make money, but the East Bank group insists any money made from the lawsuit will go to rebuild the coast.

Capture(from SLFPA-E) – Oil, gas and pipeline companies that cut at least 10,000 miles of oil and gas canals and pipelines through Louisiana coastal lands must repair the damaged environmental buffer zone that helps protect most of the greater New Orleans region from catastrophic flooding, a lawsuit filed by the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority – East (SLFPA-E) asserted today.

Filed in state district court in Orleans Parish, the lawsuit alleges about 100 defendants compromised the integrity of Louisiana’s coastal lands with activities tied to hundreds of wells and pipelines, heightening risks of hurricanes, storm surge and flooding in the region.

The SLFPA-E – which operates and maintains the complex system of levees, floodgates, seawalls, and jetties that protect about a million people and property in the greater New Orleans region – asserts in the lawsuit that the defendants are obligated by law to restore the coastal land areas.

According to the petition, “Oil and gas activities continue to transform what was once a stable ecosystem of naturally occurring bayous, small canals, and ditches into an extensive – and expanding – network of large and deep canals that continues to widen due to Defendants’ ongoing failure to maintain this network or restore the ecosystem to its natural state.  That canal network continues to introduce increasingly larger volumes of damaging saltwater, at increasingly greater velocity, ever deeper into Louisiana’s coastal landscape and interior wetlands.  The increasing intrusion of saltwater stresses the vegetation that holds wetlands together, weakening – and ultimately killing – that vegetation.  Thus weakened, the remaining soil is washed away even by minor storms.  The canal network thus comprises a highly effective system of coastal landscape degradation.  The product of this network is an ecosystem so seriously diseased that its complete demise is inevitable if no action is taken.”

Created by the Louisiana legislature as a reform board in 2006 after Hurricane Katrina, the SLFPA-E is charged with ensuring the physical and operational integrity of the regional flood risk management system, and to working with local, regional, state, and federal partners to plan, design, and construct projects that will reduce the probability and risk of flooding for the residents within its jurisdiction.

John M. Barry, vice president of the SLFPA-E and author of Rising Tide: The Great Mississippi Flood of 1927 and How It Changed America, said, “With this lawsuit, the Authority is carrying out its mandate to help protect southern Louisiana by strengthening our first line of defense against catastrophic flooding. That first defensive perimeter is of course the buffer of land and marsh that cuts down hurricane storm surge before it reaches the levees. The industry has taken about $470 billion of the state’s natural resources during the past 20 years, and we ask that it pick up its share of the increased costs of flood protections required to offset the loss of protective coastal wetlands. The industry recognizes that it is responsible for a significant part of the problem. We want energy companies to fix the part of the problem they caused – and which they promised to address. We want them to do what they said they’d do.”

The lawsuit seeks abatement and restoration of the coastal lands, including backfilling and revegetating of canals dredged and used by the defendants, and appropriate abatement and restoration activities such as wetlands creation, reef creation, land bridge construction, hydrologic restoration, shoreline protection, structural protection, bank stabilization, and ridge restoration.

The United States Geological Survey cites oil and gas activities among the primary causes of coastal land loss. According to conservative estimates, since 1932, the state has lost more than 1,900 square miles of coastal lands, enough to cover the state of Delaware, and 700 more square miles are expected to be lost in coming decades.

Mr. Barry added, “With each acre of coastal land we lose, another essential layer of flood protection goes with it, exposing us to greater danger, impairing the effectiveness of our flood defenses and making the task of safeguarding our region more difficult and more costly. The Authority had to act now to meet our responsibility to protect lives, property and natural resources.”

The SLFPA-E is represented in the litigation by Jones, Swanson, Huddell, and Garrison, LLC, of New Orleans; Fishman Haygood Phelps Walmsley Willis & Swanson, LLP, of New Orleans; and Veron, Bice, Palermo & Wilson, LLC, of Lake Charles, La.

Gladstone N. Jones, III, of Jones, Swanson, Huddell, and Garrison, LLC, said, “For decades, oil and gas companies have received thousands of permits to dredge industrial cuts, canals and pipeline rights of way into Louisiana’s coast. Industry regulations and the law are clear: these sites must be protected or repaired, but there’s little, if any, evidence that energy companies fulfilled those obligations. Instead, we have a record of coastal land loss and ruin.”

The lawsuit claims include negligence, strict liability, public nuisance, private nuisance, breach of contract, and breach of the natural servitude of drain. The obligations to restore coastal land loss and related standards of care occur under The Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899, Louisiana’s Civil Code, Louisiana’s Mineral Code, as well as other state and federal regulations.

The lawsuit is “Board of Commissioners of the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority – East, et al., v. Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, LLC, et al.,” No. 2013-6911 in the Civil District Court for the Parish of Orleans.

Advertisement