Can alligators really live in the sewer? Posted 5:49 PM, July 8, 2013, by Alyson Titkemeyer, Updated at 07:38pm, July 8, 2013 FacebookTwitterGooglePinterestLinkedInEmail × Can alligators really live in the sewer? Can alligators live in the sewer? Can they crawl up your toilet? We investigate in the Truth or Twist. We asked master plumber Eddie Faucet from Stewart Services and Tim Borgardt from the Audubon Zoo.